Contact Us
Pascack Valley Daily Voice serves Emerson, Hillsdale, Montvale, Park Ridge, River Vale, Washington Township, Westwood & Woodcliff Lake
Return to your home site


Pascack Valley Daily Voice serves Emerson, Hillsdale, Montvale, Park Ridge, River Vale, Washington Township, Westwood & Woodcliff Lake

Nearby Towns

  • Northern Highlands
    serves Allendale, Ho-Ho-Kus, Midland Park, Saddle River, Upper Saddle River & Waldwick
  • Northern Valley
    serves Harrington Park, Haworth, Northvale, Norwood, Old Tappan & Rockleigh
  • Paramus
    serves Oradell, Paramus & River Edge
Breaking News: Hackensack Bicyclist, 54, Clams Up After Being Struck, Police Say
DV Pilot police & fire

Parole hearing means another nightmare for parents of slain New Milford girl

Photo Credit: NJDOC
Photo Credit: NJDOC
Photo Credit: NJDOC

EXCLUSIVE : The father of a New Milford girl who was raped and murdered more than 35 years ago vowed to once again fight to keep her attacker behind bars after receiving word that he is again eligible for parole this April instead of in 2022 — all because of awful timing.

Kim Montelaro (FAMILY PHOTO)

“It’s like a penalty to us. We have to relive this whole nightmare all over again,” Anthony Montelaro told CLIFFVIEW PILOT this afternoon.

A state Parole Board representative called and short time earlier and told Montelaro that the board erred in denying Christopher Righetti another hearing for 144 months, according to a n Appellate Division ruling.

A controversial law that had gone into effect two months before the board’s decision became official required that “in no case shall any parole eligibility date scheduled pursuant to this subsection be more than three years following the date on which an inmate was denied release.”

As a result, the appeals judges overturned the term length.

The tragic irony for the Montelaros is that a three-member Parole Board panel imposed the 144-month period for Righetti on June 30, 2010, but the decision wasn’t officially adopted by the full board until Nov. 17 — two months after the new law went into effect.

Adding insult to injury, the state Legislature, led by Schroeder and state Senators Paul Sarlo and Loretta Weinberg, repealed the three-year maximum last year. Gov. Christie then signed the measure into law, blaming its early-release predecessor for two murders charged to former inmates let out of prison months ahead of schedule.

“From a public policy and public safety point of view, the statutory early-release law was a disaster,” Christie said, in restoring more discretion to the Parole Board to determine an inmate’s parole eligibility, rather than being required to review each case every three years.

Bob Schroeder gives support letters to Paul, Alice, Anthony Montelaro in 2009 (CLIFFVIEW PILOT photo / EXCLUSIVE)

It was less than three years ago that Anthony and Alice Montelaro, both in their 70s, came up with their son from Florida, in what turned into a successful but very stressful bid to keep Righetti behind bars at Northern State Prison in Newark.

They were supported by members of a grass-roots group then known as Keep Bergen Safe, organized by then-Washington Township Councilman Bob Schroeder, now a New Jersey state Assemblyman.

The group — now known as — brought the board nearly 1,100 e-mailed and handwritten letters opposing Righetti’s release.

Alumni from Immaculate Heart Academy “shared their stories of what a wonderful girl Kim Montelaro was, and how much she has been missed,” Schroeder said at the time .

“Parents expressed their fears for the safety of their own children if Righetti were to be released. Others wrote in to share their personal and harrowing memories of Christopher Righetti, and how scary it was when he lived in our community,” he added.

All were pleased when the Board agreed not to allow Righetti another shot for 12 years. But he appealed.

The appeals judges ruled that the Board, in addition to ignoring the new law, “did not give adequate weight to mitigating factors applicable to his case, such as his participation in behavior-specific institutional programs, above-average institutional reports, and favorable institutional adjustment, and thus was unreasonably long.”

They directed the board to give “appropriate consideration to those mitigating factors” during Righetti’s next hearing.

This creates the distinct possibility that Righetti could be released after the 36 months is up later this year.

Montelaro, who is awaiting official written confirmation, said he was told that this next parole hearing, Righetti’s fourth since he was sentenced, “probably won’t be until late spring or early summer.”

“My plan, God willing, is to come up there, go before the board and talk to them again,” the angry father told CLIFFVIEW PILOT early this afternoon.

He has already filed an OPRA request for all records regarding Righetti’s conduct in prison.


Righetti, who the appeals judges said committed a previous rape, abducted Kim from the parking lot of the Paramus Park Mall in August 1976. He took the 20-year-old honor student to a wooded area, where he raped her and stabbed her six times in the chest.

Behind bars, Righetti, now 52, joined powerlifting teams and set a state corrections record in 1996 with a 1,000-pound squat, part of a state-record total lift of 2,105 pounds.

Righetti (Courtesy NJDOC)

The Righetti saga :

Righetti ‘will rape and kill again’ if released

Parole denied for honor student’s killer

Parole hearings: Enough already

Family, supporters take fight to Trenton

Movement grows to block killer’s parole

Father of slain girl wants killer kept behind bars

SUPPORT Cliffview Pilot :

{loadposition log}

to sign up for Daily Voice's free daily emails and news alerts.

Welcome to

Pascack Valley Daily Voice!

Serves Emerson, Hillsdale, Montvale, Park Ridge, River Vale, Washington Township, Westwood & Woodcliff Lake

Get the news you need to know on the go.

Welcome to

Pascack Valley Daily Voice!

Serves Emerson, Hillsdale, Montvale, Park Ridge, River Vale, Washington Township, Westwood & Woodcliff Lake

Hi! You've read our articles so we know you like our reporting. To keep reading please join our mailing list.

Get important news about your town as it happens.